Islam’s History Makes No Geographical Sense!!

In this explosive episode, Al Fadi and Dr. Jay Smith expose the geographical and historical holes in Islam’s origin story—and compare them directly to the evidence for Christianity.

Muslims claim everything in their faith began in Mecca and Medina, yet every major Islamic writer lived hundreds or even thousands of miles away—and wrote their accounts centuries later.

The facts:
Ibn Hisham – from Basra, raised in Cairo → 990–1,200 miles away
Al Bukhari – from Bukhara → 2,600 miles away
Al Tabari – from Tabaristan → 1,700 miles away
All wrote from Baghdad or beyond—far north of Mecca and Medina

So where did Islam really begin? And why do its earliest sources show up 200–300 years after Muhammad’s supposed lifetime?

Now compare that to Christianity’s record:
Jesus’ death: 33 AD
Paul’s letters: 15–34 years later
Acts: 20–30 years later
Mark: 37 years later
Matthew & Luke: 47 years later
John: 57 years later

Every New-Testament writer either knew Jesus personally or recorded firsthand eyewitness testimony—all within one generation.

Christianity: 15–60 years later, same region.
Islam: 200–300 years later, 1,000–2,600 miles too far north.

Which story sounds more reliable?
This episode dismantles the myth that Islam’s beginnings are “perfectly preserved.”

---